What a website audit checklist covers
Quick answer
A website audit checklist is a list of checks that shows whether a site is found on Google, loads fast on a phone and says what a customer needs. It also shows whether visits turn into calls or orders, whether everyone can use the site, and whether its domain, HTTPS and logins are in order. This one has 83 checks in six lists: search health (15), speed (11), content (16), conversion (15), accessibility (12) and technical (14). Run Theo's free audit first, with no login, then work the lists on a phone in an afternoon.
Search health comes first because the other five lists only matter once visitors arrive. In Theo's audit of 10,470 small business websites, 47 percent of the 7,071 sites with search data got an estimated zero visitors a month from Google search. The median was an estimated 1 visitor a month from Google search. The report's own Limits paragraph says the sample is not random: it is the sites whose owners chose to run the audit. Both numbers are in The State of Small Business Websites 2026.
Start with the free website audit, which is run about 4,000 times a month. It takes a site address, needs no login, and reports estimated search traffic, rankings and search health with specific fixes. Every check on the other five lists can be confirmed with a phone, a browser, Google Search Console and the site's own logins.
The six lists are in the order to work them. Search health decides whether anyone arrives, and speed decides whether they wait. Content decides whether they understand, conversion whether they act and accessibility whether everyone can. The technical list is the plumbing underneath all five.
What you need before you audit a website
Plan on an afternoon for the four or five pages that lead to money. Most of that time goes to the content and conversion lists. The search health list goes faster, because part of it is reading what the free audit and Search Console already show.
- The money pages, meaning the four or five that bring in business: the homepage, the two or three service pages customers buy most, the contact page, and booking or checkout if there is one.
- Your phone on cellular data, not office Wi-Fi, because that is where slow pages and small buttons show up.
- Logins for Google Search Console and Google Analytics, if the site has them. If it has neither, that is the first technical finding, and setting them up is a 15-minute job.
- Someone outside the business who will try to get an estimate, book or order without help, while you watch and say nothing.
- A sheet with one row per check and three columns: pass, fix now, fix later. Date it, because the next audit compares against it.
How to audit a website in six steps
The lists below are long. Working them in these six steps ends the afternoon with a sorted to-do list instead of a pile of notes.
- Run the free audit. Enter the site address at theo.site/audit. No login is needed. The report shows the estimated visitors a month the site gets from Google search, the searches its pages appear for, its search health findings and the specific fixes. Write down the visitor number: it is the baseline every later audit is measured against.
- Pick the money pages (10 minutes). List the homepage, the service pages that bring in the most revenue, the contact page and any booking or checkout page. Everything else waits for a later pass. An audit that takes on 40 pages at once usually stalls.
- Read Search Console and Analytics (15 minutes). In Search Console, open Pages and note which money pages show as "Indexed". Then open Performance, set the range to three months, and note clicks, impressions and average position. In Analytics, note which pages get visits and where the visits come from. These numbers say whether the site has a traffic problem or a page problem.
- Run the stranger test on a phone (20 minutes). Give someone outside the business one real task, such as getting an estimate for a water heater, and watch without helping. Every pause, wrong tap and scroll back up is a finding for the conversion list.
- Work the six lists (two to three hours). Go through the money pages one at a time, marking each check pass, fix now or fix later. Do not fix anything yet. Stopping to fix things midway is how the second half of an audit never gets done.
- Sort, fix, retest (the following weeks). Sort the fix-now items by what each one costs the business, using the table further down. Make the fixes, re-run the free audit and the stranger test, and write the date on the sheet.
Search health checklist: how Google sees the site
Search health is whether Google has the site, shows it for the searches customers type, and sends visitors. Three of the checks below come straight from the free audit report: the estimated traffic, the searches the site ranks for and how many sites link to it. The rest take Search Console and a browser.
Buy My Lunch shows what better search health looks like in Search Console. The school lunch ordering service, a Theo customer named here with the owner's permission, moved to Theo in June 2026. Its clicks from Google search climbed from 131 in one 90-day window to 929 in the next, which ended September 27, 2026. Impressions grew from 7,500 to 61,700 across the two windows, and the average position improved from 13 to 8 as pages from the growth work went live. Clicks, impressions and position, each over two 90-day windows, are the three numbers to write on the audit sheet. The table after the checklist sets its numbers side by side.
- Google lists the site. Search site:yourdomain.com and confirm the money pages appear. Zero results means Google does not have the site at all, and nothing else on this list matters until it does.
- Search Console is verified, and its Pages report shows every money page as "Indexed". A money page marked Discovered - currently not indexed is a finding. The indexing guide gives six free steps to work through, in order.
- The Performance report shows clicks from Google search over the last three months. Clicks near zero match the report's zero-traffic group, the 47 percent of the 7,071 sites with search data that got an estimated zero visitors a month from Google search.
- Every service has its own page rather than a paragraph on one Services page, because Google ranks pages, not paragraphs.
- Every page has its own title tag naming the service and the place: "Drain Cleaning in Tulsa", not "Home" or the business name alone.
- Every page has a meta description written for a person deciding whether to click, under about 160 characters, with the service and the place in it.
- Each page has one main heading, the H1, and it matches the title tag closely enough that a searcher who clicks lands on what they expected.
- The city or service area appears in text on the homepage, each service page and the contact page, not only in a map or a logo.
- If the business serves more than one town, a service-area page lists the towns it covers. A town that brings in steady work can also have its own short page saying what is offered there. Brauntigam Plumbing, a plumbing shop's site for Fredericksburg, Texas, built by Theo, does both: a Towns menu and a short page per town. Its Kerrville page says who comes, on which days, and the trip charge. See the live site.
- The Google Business Profile shows the same name, address, phone and hours as the site and links to the homepage.
- The homepage links to every service page, and service pages link to each other and to the contact page, so Google and visitors reach everything in two clicks.
- No two pages compete for the same search: one page per service, at most one per town, and a blog post that covers the same ground as a service page links to it instead of repeating it.
- You know which searches the site ranks for, because the free audit lists them. The searches customers type that are missing from that list are the pages to write next.
- Other sites link to yours: directories, suppliers, associations, the chamber of commerce, local press. In Theo's audit of 10,470 small business websites, 65 percent of the 9,836 sites with link data had a Semrush Authority Score of 5 or less. Semrush builds that score largely from the sites linking to a domain.
- Something new has been published since launch. Search Console shows when each page was last crawled. A site with nothing new for a year gives Google no reason to come back.
| Search Console, Buy My Lunch | The 90 days before | The 90 days to September 27, 2026 |
|---|---|---|
Clicks from Google search | 131 | 929 |
Search impressions | 7,500 | 61,700 |
Average position | 13 | 8 |
Speed checklist: how fast the site loads on a phone
Check speed on a phone on cellular data, on the money pages only. A page that takes more than a few seconds to show its headline loses the visitor before the content list gets a chance.
- The headline and main button of each money page appear within a few seconds on cellular data. Count the seconds out loud, because a laptop on office Wi-Fi hides the problem.
- Photos are exported at the size they display, not straight from the camera. A 4,000-pixel photo shown 800 pixels wide is a common speed finding on a small business site.
- The largest image on each page, usually the top one, is compressed and loads first, before anything below it.
- Nothing moves while the page loads. A headline that jumps when a banner or font arrives makes visitors tap the wrong thing.
- The site uses one or two font families, and text stays visible in a fallback font while they load.
- Every widget earns its place: chat bubbles, social feeds, review carousels and embedded maps each add load time, and a static map image with a link costs almost nothing.
- Video is embedded from a video host rather than uploaded to the site, and it does not autoplay on phones.
- Images below the first screen load only when the visitor scrolls to them, so the first screen is not waiting on the gallery at the bottom.
- Pages are served as plain files rather than built from a database on every visit. Theo builds and hosts every site as static files served over HTTPS, which is why this check passes there by default.
- Pages and images are served from servers near the visitor, so someone two states away is not waiting on one machine.
- The slowest money page is timed again after the fixes, on the same phone and the same connection, and both times go on the sheet.
Content checklist: what every important page needs to say
Content is what each page says and whether a stranger can act on it. This list is a walk-through of the money pages. A larger site that needs a page-by-page inventory with traffic numbers should use the spreadsheet method in the website content audit instead.
The home page below, from Aukamp Heating & Cooling, a site Theo built, passes the first two checks on its first screen.
- The first screen of the homepage answers three questions without scrolling: what the business does, who it is for, and what to do next.
- No line on the first screen could belong to a competitor. "Same-week furnace repair in Dayton" beats "quality you can trust".
- The homepage names the three or four services that make the most money, in that order, instead of every service alphabetically.
- Every service page says who it is for, what is included, how the work goes, how long it takes and what the next step is.
- Price context sits where the decision is made: a starting price, a range, a minimum, or a sentence on how estimates work.
- Proof sits beside the claim it supports: a review beside the promise, a license number beside the word licensed, a photo of the crew beside the word team.
- Business details are identical on every page and on the Google Business Profile: name, phone, email, address, hours, service area.
- The questions customers ask before buying are answered on the page, not saved for a phone call: do you serve my town, do you take my insurance, how soon can you come.
- Stale material is gone: services no longer offered, staff who left, expired promotions, last year's prices, holiday hours from a previous year.
- The About page says who runs the business, how long it has run and why a customer should trust it, with a photo of a real person.
- Photos show the actual business, its people and its work. A stock photo of a handshake tells a visitor nothing and is recognized as stock.
- Headings say what the section answers, paragraphs carry one idea, and steps, inclusions and prices are lists rather than prose.
- Link text names the page it goes to, so "click here" and "learn more" are gone.
- No price, instruction or offer exists only inside a graphic. Anything in an image is also written out on the page.
- Each page has one job. Detail that belongs to another service goes on that service's own page, with a link to it.
- Package names, the steps of the process and trade terms are explained the first time they appear, in the words a customer would use.

Conversion checklist: the path from a visit to a call
Conversion is the path from a visit to a call, booking or order. Test it as a first-time visitor on a phone, using only the menu, and count the taps.
The contact page below passes several of these checks at once. Brindlecrest Counseling Group is a group practice's site for Worthington, Ohio, built by Theo. On its first screen it says who replies and when (Tasha, within one business day), gives the phone number, email, address and office hours as text, and keeps the form to a name, an email, an optional phone and one question: what would be most helpful right now? See the live site.
- The site has one main action, named: call, request an estimate, book or order. Every money page points to it.
- Each page has one primary button, and competing buttons are demoted to text links.
- The main action is visible on the first screen of a phone and again at the end of every service page.
- The phone number is a tap-to-call link in the header and the footer.
- The contact form works: a test message lands in an inbox someone reads daily, and the sender sees a thank-you that says who replies and when.
- The form asks only what is needed to reply: usually a name, a phone number or email, and a short message. A full project brief before a first conversation stops people.
- Booking, quote and checkout links open the right tool on the right service, on a phone as well as a laptop.
- Homepage to service to contact takes two or three taps using only the menu.
- Nothing covers the action: no pop-up over the button, no cookie or chat bar over the phone number.
- A visitor who is not ready today has a next step: a price guide, examples of work or an FAQ.
- The menu opens with one hand and reaches every money page, and its label is a word, not an icon alone.
- Text is readable without zooming, and buttons are big enough to tap without hitting the next one.
- The contact page carries the address as a link that opens the phone's map app, the hours, the phone number as text and how fast replies come.
- If the site has a chat widget, a person answers it during business hours. A chat nobody answers is worse than no chat.
- Someone outside the business completes a real task with no help. Every pause is a fix.

Accessibility checklist: can everyone use the site
Accessibility is whether someone using a screen reader, a keyboard or a zoomed-in phone can use the site, and whether it can be read in a bright parking lot. These 12 checks are a first pass, and the ADA compliance checklist explains what WCAG 2.1 AA asks of a small business site and what to do about a demand letter.
- Text has strong contrast, dark on light or light on dark. Light gray on white and white text over a photo both fail on a phone in sunlight.
- Every image that carries meaning has a written description, and purely decorative images are marked so screen readers skip them.
- Every form field has a visible label above or beside it, not only gray placeholder text that vanishes when typing starts.
- The whole site can be used with the Tab key alone: every link, button and menu item can be reached, and a visible outline shows which one is selected.
- Headings are real headings in order, one H1 then H2s and H3s, not bold text made larger.
- Text can be enlarged to 200 percent in the browser without overlapping, cut-off words or a sideways scroll.
- Video has captions and audio has a transcript, on the page or one click away.
- Nothing flashes, and anything that moves on its own, such as a carousel, can be paused or stopped.
- Color is never the only signal: a required field is marked with a word, or an asterisk explained in text, not only a red outline.
- The message a form shows when something is wrong says what to fix, in words, next to the field where the mistake is.
- The page language is set to English in the code so screen readers pronounce the words correctly. Most platforms have one setting for it.
- Pop-ups and cookie bars can be closed with the keyboard and do not trap the keyboard inside them.
Technical checklist: the domain, HTTPS, links and logins
Most technical checks can be confirmed in a browser. The rest need the domain and hosting logins, and knowing where those are is itself the first check.
- The domain registrar login works, auto-renew is on, and the renewal date is written down where the business will see it.
- The hosting and platform logins are known to the business, not only to a former developer or agency.
- Every page loads over HTTPS with no warning, and the http address redirects to https.
- The HTTPS certificate renews on its own. To check it, click the icon to the left of the address: a padlock in Safari and Firefox, a tune icon in Chrome. If the browser shows a warning there instead, see what each warning means. Open the certificate details and read the expiry date. If your host renews automatically, a date a few weeks away is normal; if it is only days away or past, ask the host.
- The www and non-www addresses land on one site, not two copies. The www guide explains how to pick one and redirect the other.
- No link on the money pages leads to a page-not-found. Click every menu link, footer link and button once to be sure.
- The page-not-found page is the site's own, with the menu and a link back to the homepage.
- Search Console has received the XML sitemap and reports it as processed, with nothing flagged.
- No robots.txt rule and no noindex tag keeps Google out of a page that should rank. Search Console's URL inspection shows both.
- Nothing displays sideways on a phone: no horizontal scrolling, overlapping text or cut-off tables.
- Analytics is installed and receiving visits, and Search Console is verified on the same domain and address the visitors use.
- On WordPress or any platform with plugins, updates and backups are current, and a backup has been restored once to prove it works.
- Email to the business address still arrives after any domain or hosting change. Send a test, because email records are easy to lose in a domain change.
- A privacy policy page is linked in the footer, and if the business runs ads, the Meta or TikTok pixel is installed and firing.
The website audit checklist in one table
The table puts the six lists side by side: what each needs, how long it takes, how often to repeat it and who usually does it. For a site that takes bookings or orders, or runs ads, the first four lists move to monthly.
| List | Checks | What you need | Time | How often | Who |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Search health | 15 | Free audit, Search Console | 30 minutes | Quarterly, plus after any new page | Owner, or Theo on Starter and Pro |
Speed | 11 | Phone on cellular data | 20 minutes | Quarterly, plus after new photos or widgets | Owner, or Theo on Starter and Pro |
Content | 16 | The money pages, a stranger | 45 to 60 minutes | Quarterly, plus after any change to services, prices or staff | Owner, since nobody else knows the business |
Conversion | 15 | Phone, a stranger, a test form | 30 minutes | Quarterly, or monthly with bookings, orders or ads | Owner and whoever answers the phone |
Accessibility | 12 | Keyboard, browser zoom | 20 minutes | Yearly, plus after a redesign | Owner, or whoever builds the pages |
Technical | 14 | Registrar, hosting and Search Console logins | 20 minutes | Yearly for logins and renewals, quarterly for links and HTTPS | Owner (Theo hosts the site over HTTPS on every plan) |
What to fix first after a website audit
The 83 checks produce a long list. Sort it by what each finding costs the business, not by how easy it is to fix. Easy fixes get done in the middle of an audit, and the expensive ones get postponed.
- A worked example. Suppose a two-truck plumbing company's audit turns up 19 findings. Three are fix-now: the estimate form has been sending to a former office manager's inbox, a site:yourdomain.com search shows only the homepage, and the phone number in the header is plain text. Seven are fix-next. Among them, water heaters, drains and repiping share one Services page, every title tag says "Home", and the reviews sit at the bottom of the About page. The remaining nine, such as a second font, a slow Instagram feed and a missing page-not-found page, go on next quarter's list.
- The form takes ten minutes to fix and is worth more than the other 18 findings together, which is why cost to the business, not effort, sets the order.
| Priority | What belongs here | Next move |
|---|---|---|
Fix now | A site not in Google's index or getting zero search visitors, a contact form landing in an unread inbox, a phone number that cannot be tapped, a domain renewal or certificate about to lapse, a booking or checkout link that opens the wrong thing | Repair this week, then re-run the free audit and the stranger test |
Fix next | Services without their own page, titles that say "Home", a first screen that could be any business, proof at the bottom, a pop-up over the button, photos straight from the camera | Rewrite or rebuild the page, then re-test the path on a phone |
Plan later | Extra examples of work, secondary pages, font tidying, widgets that are unnecessary rather than slow, captions for old videos | Add to the next quarterly pass with a date |
Website audit mistakes that waste the afternoon
Six mistakes come up in almost every first audit. Each has a fix that costs nothing.
- Auditing on a laptop on office Wi-Fi. The fix: the phone on cellular data, because that is where the speed and conversion lists fail.
- Auditing every page. The fix: the four or five money pages this quarter, and the rest on later passes.
- Chasing a tool's score. A score of 100 from a speed or SEO tool is not the goal. The goal is a visitor who finds the page, understands it and calls. The fix: mark checks pass or fail against the lists, and use scores only to spot a change between passes.
- Fixing as you go. The fix: finish the lists first, then sort, then fix. Next quarter's pass is measured against the dated sheet, and a half-finished sheet leaves it nothing to measure against.
- Skipping Search Console because it looks technical. The fix: open only the Pages and Performance reports. Those two screens answer the question that matters first, whether Google is sending anyone at all.
- Never re-running the audit. The fix: re-run the free audit and the stranger test after the fix-now items, and put the next full pass on the calendar before closing the sheet.
How often to audit a website
The search health, speed, content and conversion lists are a quarterly job for most small businesses. A site that takes bookings or orders, or that runs ads, needs them every month. Accessibility and the technical list's login and renewal checks are yearly, while its link and HTTPS checks ride with the quarterly pass. Three events call for a partial pass in between.
- A change to the business, such as a new service, new hours or a new team member: run the content and search health lists on the pages it touches.
- A campaign, busy season or new ad spend: run the conversion and speed lists on the pages the campaign lands on, before the money is spent.
- A redesign or platform move: run every list, because rankings, redirects and forms are what a move most often loses. Confirm that the old addresses that still get traffic redirect to the matching new page.
How much a website audit costs
Theo's website audit is free, needs no login and runs on any live site. An agency audit is usually a one-off fee or the first step of a monthly retainer. The price depends on how many pages the agency reads and whether it makes the fixes. Before paying, ask which lists it covers, because a technical-only audit leaves four of these six lists untouched.
The fixes usually cost more than the audit. Basic, at $29.99 a month, is the site and managed hosting, plus 1,500 chat credits a month for the changes the owner asks for in chat. Basic has no ongoing SEO program. Starter, at $69.99 a month and free for the first 30 days, adds the ongoing work that the search health, speed and technical lists turn up. That work covers keyword and competitor research, new pages and posts, technical SEO fixes and page speed work. On every plan, connecting Google also submits the sitemap. New pages, posts and fixes wait in the Growth tab until the owner publishes them, and none of it uses chat credits. Pro, at $129.99 a month, adds more weekly pages and posts, 7,000 chat credits and read-only access to the site code.
Frequently asked questions
What should a website audit checklist include?
It should cover six lists. The first, search health, is whether Google has the site and sends visitors. Speed is how fast the site loads on a phone, content is whether each page says what a customer needs, and conversion is whether the path to a call or order works. Accessibility is whether everyone can use it, and technical is whether the domain, HTTPS, links and logins are in order. A checklist that covers only one of these, usually SEO or design, finds only that list's problems.
How do I audit a website myself?
Start with the free audit for a search health baseline, then pick the four or five pages that lead to money. Read the Pages and Performance reports in Search Console, and have someone outside the business complete one real task on a phone while you watch. After that, work the six lists page by page, marking each check pass, fix now or fix later. Sort the fix-now items by what they cost the business. If a site:yourdomain.com search returns nothing at all, stop and work through the guide to a site not showing up on Google first.
How long does a website audit take?
The free audit needs only the site address. The other five lists take an afternoon, two to three hours on the four or five money pages, with most of it spent on the content and conversion lists. The fixes take longer than the checks. Writing a service page from nothing takes the longest.
How much does a website audit cost?
Theo's audit costs nothing and asks for no login. An agency either charges a one-off fee or folds the audit into the first month of a retainer, and the fixes are usually billed on top. On Theo, the technical SEO fixes and page speed work the lists turn up are part of the ongoing work on Starter and Pro, and connecting Google submits the site's sitemap on every plan so Google finds every new page. Starter is $69.99 a month and free for the first 30 days.
If Theo makes the fixes, who owns the site and can it be canceled?
The pages, words and photos are yours on every plan, including every page the fix-now and fix-next items add. Theo hosts the site, and on Pro you can also read and copy its code through GitHub. Nothing locks you in: you can cancel at any time, and the confirmation names the date the subscription ends. The site stays live until then, so on Basic or Starter save your text and images before that date. The dated audit sheet is your own record either way, so the next pass has its baseline wherever the site is hosted.
What is the difference between a website audit and a content audit?
A website audit is a walk-through of the money pages against lists like the six above, done in an afternoon on a phone. A content audit is a spreadsheet: every page on the site in a row, with its traffic, its rankings and a decision to keep, update, merge or remove it. A site with 10 pages needs the first. A site with 80 pages needs both, and the content audit says which pages to walk through.
Does a website audit mean I need a redesign?
Not usually. Most audits produce focused fixes: a missing service page, a form going to the wrong inbox, a title that says "Home", a photo that needs compressing. A redesign makes sense in only two cases. One is a structure that cannot support how customers decide. The other is a platform that cannot pass the speed and technical lists no matter what is fixed on it.
How often should I audit my website?
Run the search health, speed, content and conversion lists quarterly, or monthly if the site takes bookings or orders or runs ads. Accessibility and the login and renewal checks are yearly. Add a partial pass whenever the business changes, a campaign starts or the site moves platforms. At the end of each pass, put the next date on the sheet.
Working the website audit checklist with Theo
Theo builds the site as static files served over HTTPS and hosts it on every plan, which gives the speed and technical lists a head start. On Starter ($69.99 a month, free for the first 30 days) and Pro, Theo also works on what the search health list turns up. The work covers keyword and competitor research, drafts of the missing service and town pages, and technical SEO and speed fixes. The drafts wait in the Growth tab for the owner to publish, and a weekly email counts what was added. Run the free website audit for a search health baseline. If the site fails so much of this checklist that it is not worth fixing, build a new one free and see it before you decide.
More like this in the guides and under building a small business website. The audit numbers quoted across these posts are in Theo's research.



