Website design for insurance agencies

Insurance Agency Website Design

An insurance agency website from Theo is built around the lines you write, the carriers you represent and the way your office quotes. Theo builds and hosts it from $29.99 a month on Basic. Starter, $69.99 a month and free for the first 30 days, adds the weekly search work that helps the agency get found for the coverage it sells.

Theo robot assistant
  • Six insurance agency sites to open on your phone, from a flood agency to a Medicare office
  • One page per line you write: auto, home, umbrella, life, business owner's policy, workers' comp
  • A quote door for shoppers and a separate door for claims, certificates and service
  • Hosting and chat changes on every plan; coverage and town pages drafted weekly on Starter and Pro

Insurance agency web design comes down to two visitors. A shopper wants to see in seconds that you write their coverage in their town, and how to get a quote. A client wants to report a claim, add a car or get a certificate without landing in a sales form. So the first screen gives each a door, every line you write gets a page, and each producer appears with a photo and the states they are licensed in. Theo writes and builds that site from a conversation about your agency. The site with hosting is $29.99 a month on Basic. Starter is $69.99 a month, free for the first 30 days, and adds the ongoing search work. The first build is free, and six agency sites Theo built sit just below.

In Theo's audit of 10,470 small business websites, 49 percent of the 565 professional services sites with search data got an estimated zero visitors a month from Google search, and 69 percent got fewer than ten. See the research.

What the site needs

What an insurance agency website needs

Two people open an agency's site, and they want different things. The shopper wants four answers fast: do you write the policy I need, do you write it where I live, how do I get a quote, and who would I be dealing with. The client, often after hours, wants a fifth: where do I report a claim, add a car or get a certificate. The points below settle both, most with words to adapt and a picture from one of the agency sites above that does it, linked to the live site so you can try it on your phone.

Brunvald Insurance home page, built by Theo: Get a contractor quote beside Request a certificate under the headline, the phone number in the header, and a strip reading Contractors only, Same-day certificates and Founded by a former framer above the six towns it serves
Built by TheoBrunvald InsuranceTwo doors side by side under the headline, the phone number in the header, and the towns named in one line before any scrolling.See the live site
01

Two doors on the first screen

The top of the home page has to work for the shopper and the client at the same time. Read down a good one and you find, in order:

1. The lines and the towns in one sentence a caller could repeat ('Home, auto and small business insurance for Wausau and Marathon County', not 'protecting what matters most').

2. A line saying the agency is independent and compares several insurance companies, if it is.

3. A 'Get a quote' button.

4. Beside it, never inside the quote path, a second door for existing clients.

5. A phone number that dials with one tap, with the hours and who answers.

6. A smaller 'Client service' link in the header.

7. The licensed states as plain text, not inside an image.

8. A real photo of the office or the people in it.

Kettlehaus pairs 'Get a quote' with 'Schedule a renewal review'. Brunvald pairs 'Get a contractor quote' with 'Request a certificate'. Callowell splits the screen into 'For families' and 'For employers' and puts 'Ohio licensed' in the strip under the photo. Hallendine runs its number and weekday hours in a strip above the menu.

Pelloquin leads with what a homeowners policy leaves out before it asks for anything.

Kettlehaus Insurance home page, built by Theo: Independent insurance in Wausau since 1991 above the headline, a line about comparing several insurance companies, and Get a quote beside Schedule a renewal review
Built by TheoKettlehaus InsuranceWho and where above the headline, the independent line under it, and buttons that name each step.See the live site
02

Words that work on it, and on the pages behind it

These lines are examples to adapt, and each one only works if it is true of your office.

Headlines: 'Home, auto and small business insurance for Wausau and Marathon County.' 'Insurance for contractors in the Sioux Falls area: liability, workers' comp and same-day certificates.' 'Life insurance for young families, explained in plain words.'

Buttons that name the step: 'Get a quote' and 'Report a claim', side by side, and the phone number itself as a button with 'A licensed agent answers weekdays 8 to 5' under it. Leave 'Get started' and 'Submit' off.

The independent line: 'We're an independent agency. We compare policies from several insurance companies and work for you, not for one company.'

Under the quote button: 'Send this and a licensed agent calls you within one business day.'

Above the form: 'Please don't send your driver's license number, Social Security number or policy documents here. We'll ask for what we need on the phone.'

On the claims page: 'If anyone is hurt, call 911 first. Then call your insurance company's claims line below; it's open 24 hours. Then call us, and we'll help with what comes next.'

For certificates: 'Send the job address and the certificate holder's exact name and address.'

For service: 'Already a client? To add a car, change an address or get an ID card, call Dale at the office.'

In the footer: 'Licensed in Wisconsin and Michigan. Wisconsin agency license No.' followed by your own license number.

Solvanez Insurance home page, built by Theo: Three kinds of insurance. One person to call., cards for Auto, Homeowners and Renters, each with a See what I check link, and a More on the way note below
Built by TheoSolvanez InsuranceThree lines, a card each, then a More on the way note that names the lines still to come and ends with Call me anyway.See the live site
03

The pages an insurance agency website needs

A one-office personal lines agency usually starts with 15 to 20 pages and adds town pages over time.

Home, which sends each visitor to the right door.

Personal insurance: an overview, then one page per line you write: auto, home, renters, condo, umbrella, motorcycle, boat and RV, flood, life.

Business insurance: an overview, then one per line: business owner's policy, general liability, workers' comp, commercial auto, professional liability, bonds, cyber.

Pages for the clients you want more of: contractors, restaurants, landlords, parents of new drivers, farms, small employers.

Get a quote. Report a claim, with every carrier's 24-hour line. Client service, for changes, ID cards and billing. Certificates of insurance, if you write commercial.

Our carriers, by name. Why an independent agency, or About. Our team. A link to your real reviews. Towns we serve. Contact and directions.

A privacy page that says what the forms collect. And, only if you sell Medicare, a page that carries the notice the rules require.

Skip any line you cannot place today. Solvanez lists its three lines, then a 'More on the way' note for the rest that ends: 'Call me anyway. If I can't place it, I'll tell you who can.'

Brunvald Insurance workers' comp page, built by Theo: What we need to quote, five numbered lines from the FEIN and a description of the work to three years of loss runs, then a Start my quote button
Built by TheoBrunvald InsuranceThe workers' comp page lists what a quote needs in five numbered lines, explains the audit in plain words, then offers Start my quote.See the live site
04

One page per coverage line, ending in what you need to quote it

Each line gets a page of its own, and it ends in the quote button. The page says who buys it, what it covers in plain words, what it usually leaves out and where to get that, what a producer needs to quote it and which kinds of carriers can place it. A page per line lets Google show the agency for 'landlord insurance' in your county, not only for its name.

The 'what we need to quote' list does the most work, because it turns a vague call into a ready one.

Kettlehaus's Home and auto page has two short columns. For the home: the roof's age and material, the year the wiring, plumbing and heat were last updated, any wood stove or outdoor wood boiler, and the mortgage company. For the cars: each driver's birth date, the miles driven and where each one is parked at night. It adds that the current declarations pages answer most of it.

Brunvald's workers' comp page asks for the FEIN, next year's payroll split by field labor, driving, estimating and office, the subs and their coverage, and three years of loss runs.

Solvanez's auto page sets Georgia's 25/50/25 minimum against the 100/300/100 she usually suggests, and explains the two kinds of uninsured motorist coverage before anyone signs.

Callowell Life & Benefits new parents page, built by Theo: the headline It's 3 a.m., the baby finally fell asleep, and you're doing the math, a Book a coverage review button and a photo of two parents holding a baby
Built by TheoCallowell Life & BenefitsThe new parents page opens in a tired parent's own words, with one button: Book a coverage review.See the live site
05

Pages by client type, and by trade

A landlord, a contractor, a restaurant owner, a new driver's parent and a small employer each ask different questions, so each gets a page in its own vocabulary.

Brunvald gives roofers, electricians and landscapers a page each with the same three parts, What we place, What trips up your trade and What we need to quote, written in that trade's words: torch-down and storm work across state lines for roofers, a fire two years after the job and tools stolen from the van for electricians, the plow and the sprayer for landscapers.

Callowell writes its new parents page the way a tired parent thinks ('It's 3 a.m., the baby finally fell asleep, and you're doing the math'), with coverage amounts, term lengths and who can receive the money while the child is a baby.

Its employer page puts the group health rules in plain words: most insurance companies want the employer to pay at least half the employee-only premium and about 70 percent of eligible staff to enroll or show other coverage, and from November 15 to December 15 a small employer can start a plan without meeting those minimums.

Hallendine does the same for Medicare, with a page for people turning 65 and one for people still working at 65.

Theo writes pages like these from a conversation about who actually calls the office, and each ends in the quote or booking button.

Kettlehaus Insurance quote page, built by Theo: a boxed line saying the form never asks for a driver's license or Social Security number, above fields for name, phone, email, best time to call, home address, drivers and vehicles
Built by TheoKettlehaus InsuranceThe promise sits above the first field, and the note beside the form says a license number is asked for only on the phone.See the live site
06

A quote form that asks little, and says what it never asks

Ask what starts the conversation, not what underwrites the policy. If the agency has an online quote link from its comparative rater or a carrier, 'Get a quote' can go straight there. If the office quotes by phone, the button opens a request form, and the form decides whether people finish.

A short form, with a name, a phone or email, the coverage wanted and the renewal date, is the easiest to finish on a phone; Pelloquin's flood request asks five things.

Kettlehaus asks more, drivers' birth dates and vehicles included, so the producer can compare companies before calling. It earns the trust back with one sentence above the first field: 'This form never asks for your driver's license number or your Social Security number.' Beside the form it adds that a license number is asked for only on the phone, once the client decides to go ahead, and never by email or text. Hallendine's appointment form makes the same promise about Medicare and Social Security numbers.

Whichever length you pick, keep driver's license numbers, Social Security numbers, VINs and uploaded documents off the website form. Then say how soon a licensed person calls back, right under the button.

Pelloquin Insurance storm checklist box, built by Theo: Who to call, in order, listing the agency's number first, then the flood claims line, the wind or homeowners claims line, the mortgage company and the county emergency office
Built by TheoPelloquin InsuranceThe storm checklist ends with who to call, in order, starting with the agency, and says flood and wind are separate claims.See the live site
07

Claims and service, kept apart from sales

A client adding a car should never land in a quote form, and one with a kitchen fire at midnight should find the claims number without calling the office.

Give claims a page of its own, linked from the header: 'If anyone is hurt, call 911 first,' then each carrier's 24-hour claims line, tap to call, with its online claims link, then the agency's own number for help with what comes next. Add a 'Print a claims card for your glovebox' link: one page with each carrier's line and the agency's number, the thing an older client actually keeps.

Give service a page too: how to add a car or driver, change an address, get an ID card, reach each carrier's billing page, and the name of the person who handles it.

The six sites show pieces of this. Pelloquin's storm checklist ends in a 'Who to call, in order' box that starts with the agency, then the flood company, then the wind or homeowners company, and says flood and wind are separate claims. Kettlehaus's contact page tells clients to call the carrier's 24-hour line after hours, then the agency. Callowell, Solvanez and Hallendine each name the person clients call for ID cards.

Put a 'Report a claim' button on the first screen as well, and when a carrier changes its number or an appointment ends, one line in chat updates the page.

Brunvald Insurance certificate page, built by Theo: a Send us the job details form asking for the business name, phone, email, certificate holder and job address, beside a dark Before you sign the contract box with the most common limits and endorsement timing
Built by TheoBrunvald InsuranceThe certificate form asks for the holder and the job address, and the box beside it says what contracts usually ask for and how long new wording takes.See the live site
08

Certificates of insurance, for commercial agencies

A contractor's day can hinge on a certificate, so a commercial agency gives the request its own page and its own button on the first screen. Brunvald's 'Need a certificate before the job starts?' page shows the shape.

The form asks for the business name, phone and email, the certificate holder's name and mailing address, the job address and start date, and what the contract asks for: additional insured, waiver of subrogation, primary and non-contributory.

Above it sits one plain promise: requests in by 2:00pm on a business day go out the same day, emailed to the contractor and the holder.

Beside it, a 'Before you sign the contract' box sets expectations: the most common ask it names is $1 million per occurrence and $2 million aggregate, and wording the policy does not already have needs an endorsement from the insurance company, which it says usually takes 1 to 3 business days. The contract's insurance page goes by email, not through the form.

Write the promise your office actually keeps, and if certificates go out on Saturday mornings, say so next to the hours, as Brunvald does.

Kettlehaus Insurance renewal review page, built by Theo: Life moves. Your policy should keep up., a checklist of nine changes from a new driver and a child at college to a home business and the cost to rebuild
Built by TheoKettlehaus InsuranceThe renewal page's checklist: nine life changes that can leave a policy out of date, one per line.See the live site
09

A renewal page that gives clients a reason to call

Renewal is when clients drift, so the site can make it the moment they call instead.

Kettlehaus invites every client to a 20-minute review about 45 days before renewal, by phone, video or at the office, and lists what actually changes a policy: a teen with a learner's permit, a child at college more than 100 miles away without a car, a paid-off car, a new roof, a finished basement without water backup coverage, a new kitchen that raises the cost to rebuild, jewelry or guns worth more than the policy's limit, a home business. Each review ends with a one-page summary, and the page closes with 'Pick a time for your review' and the account manager's name.

For employers, Callowell lays out the group renewal as five steps, from the day the new rates arrive 60 to 90 days out, to one page of side-by-side choices within two weeks, to open enrollment 30 days before the renewal date.

Hallendine invites every Medicare client to a review each fall and ends each one with a one-page letter: stay where you are, or switch and why.

All three answer the question a busy client never gets around to asking: is anything about my coverage out of date?

Callowell Life & Benefits team page, built by Theo: Simone Callowell's photo, Founder and Chartered Life Underwriter, licensed in life and health in Ohio, beside a Book a coverage review with Simone button
Built by TheoCallowell Life & BenefitsSimone's bio carries her photo, her designation spelled out, the state she is licensed in and a booking button with her name on it.See the live site
10

Producers a shopper can check

A referral looks the producer up before calling, so each bio carries what a shopper can check. That means a real photo, the lines that person handles, the states they are licensed in, any designation spelled out, and a direct phone, email or booking link.

Callowell puts a 'Book a coverage review with Simone' button beside each producer's bio. It opens that person's own two weeks of 30-minute times, with Tuesday and Thursday evening video slots for the two who see new parents, and it says plainly that a picked time is a request the office confirms by email.

Solvanez is built for the referral: the first screen says 'If a friend sent you, you're in the right place,' then gives Renata's own three sentences about nine years in claims, her name and town, and her cell number in large type.

A link to your state's license lookup beside the bios lets a careful shopper confirm a license in a minute, and a link to the agency's Google reviews belongs near the quote button, real reviews only.

Kettlehaus and Hallendine show their people as letters in circles; photos of the people who actually answer your phone will do more than any stock picture.

Solvanez Insurance companies page, built by Theo: three current appointments listed as plain text, each available to quote, with a note that logos wait for each company's written permission
Built by TheoSolvanez InsuranceThe three companies it quotes appear as plain text, with a line saying each logo waits for that company's written permission.See the live site
11

Your license, your carriers and their products

From here down are the rules your state and your carriers check, in plain words; read them as a checklist, not as legal advice.

Advertise under the name on the agency's license, or a name registered with the state, and list the states the agency and each producer are licensed in.

Some states want the license number on advertising. California's Insurance Code section 1725.5 requires it on business cards, written price quotes and print ads, and since January 1, 2023 on emails about licensed work, as the California Department of Insurance notice explains. Many agencies put the number in the website footer as well; check your own state's rule.

Carrier names belong only to current appointments, and logos only with each carrier's permission, since most carriers have brand rules for agents. When an appointment ends, the name, the logo and the claims line come off together. Solvanez shows the patient version: its three companies appear as plain text with 'Names only until each company gives written permission to show its logo.'

A page that explains a kind of coverage is the agency's own, but carriers commonly want to approve an ad for a named product, especially life insurance, annuities and Medicare plans.

A captive agent should read the agent agreement before building a separate site, since many captive carriers supply the agent's page and set its rules.

Hallendine Medicare Advisors footer, built by Theo: the Arizona license line, the notice that the agency does not offer every plan with its counts of organizations and products, and a line saying it is not connected with Medicare
Built by TheoHallendine Medicare AdvisorsEvery page ends with the license line, the notice with its counts filled in, and a line saying the agency is not connected with Medicare.See the live site
12

Medicare agents: the notice the rules require

An agency that sells Medicare Advantage plans for more than one plan company owes a standard notice on its website. The rules call it a third-party marketing organization and require the notice to be prominently displayed on its website (42 CFR 422.2267(e)(41), checked October 2026).

For an agency that does not sell for every plan company in the area, the words are: 'We do not offer every plan available in your area. Currently we represent X organizations which offer Y products in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov or 1-800-MEDICARE to get information on all of your options.' Here X and Y are your own counts of plan companies and plans. An agency that sells for all of them uses the second version the same section gives.

Fill in the counts, keep them current, and put the notice on the home page and in the footer rather than on a page nobody opens. Hallendine, the sixth site above, carries it in every footer with its counts filled in, beside a line saying the agency is not connected with Medicare. Its version also names the local State Health Insurance Program, which the section's current text does not, so take your exact words from the rule itself.

Keep the Medicare card, the CMS logo and anything that suggests the agency is Medicare itself off the site.

Give the Annual Enrollment Period, October 15 to December 7, a page of its own that says what to bring: the Medicare card, a medication list and the doctors' names. Hallendine calls its page Fall Review.

A plan discussion starts with a Scope of Appointment, so the booking link can lead to the form your agency uses. Hallendine's booking page explains that short form in one paragraph, next to the request form.

The section has changed most years, so check it each spring and again before October 15.

Hallendine Medicare Advisors appointment page, built by Theo: three ways to meet, a box saying the form never asks for a Medicare or Social Security number, a paragraph on the short form Medicare asks for, and the appointment form
Built by TheoHallendine Medicare AdvisorsBeside the form: what it never asks for, the short form Medicare asks people to sign first, and who calls back within one business day.See the live site
13

Gifts, reviews and what the forms collect

Check gifts against your state's rules, quote only real reviews, and say what each form collects.

A gift card for a quote can run into your state's anti-rebating and inducement rules. The NAIC changed its model law in 2020 so that states can allow some value-added services and small gifts, but each state decides whether to adopt it and sets its own limits, so check yours before offering anything. None of the six sites offers a gift.

Reviews fall under a federal rule: the FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials (16 CFR Part 465, in force since October 21, 2024) bars fake reviews and paying for positive ones. Quote real reviews as written, with the client's permission, or link to the agency's Google reviews; never a made-up star rating or review count.

On every form, say who reads it and how the agency will get back in touch, and if the office texts, the form says so. A privacy page says what the forms collect.

Keep the type large, describe every photo for screen readers, caption any video and make each button big enough for a thumb.

14

What it costs and how long it takes

The companies that sell agency websites price them in different ways, and Theo's terms fit in a paragraph.

Other platforms: a few post a monthly price, the two largest quote after a sales demo, some add setup fees or sell a one-time build, and stated launch times run from three days to three weeks (the comparison table below, October 2026).

With Theo: the first build is free and comes before any plan, and when you publish and point the domain, the old site keeps answering clients until the records switch, usually within a few hours. Basic covers the site, hosting and changes typed in chat; Starter, free for the first 30 days, adds the weekly search work; Pro adds more pages each week and read-only code access. The plan table below has the prices.

What the agency brings: the facts about its lines, carriers, producers, licenses and towns; a logo and real photos; the rater, portal, claims and billing links; carrier permission for any logo; and, for Medicare, the counts for the notice.

What Theo does not do: rating, quoting, binding, premium payments, the client portal, e-signatures or document storage. The site links to the tools that do.

15

Eight questions to ask any insurance website company

Ask these before you sign with anyone, Theo included. Theo's own answer follows each one.

1. If I cancel, does the site stay up, and do I keep the pages and the words? Theo: the site stays live to the end of the paid period, and the pages, words and photos are yours to keep.

2. Are the coverage pages written for my agency, or drawn from a library other agencies publish too? Theo: written for your agency.

3. Is the price on your website, and is there a setup fee, an annual term or a one-time build fee? Theo: yes, on the pricing page, with a free first build, no setup fee and no term contract.

4. How long until it is live, and how much of my time does it take? Theo: a first preview usually in minutes, then your review sets the pace.

5. What does a change cost, and how fast is it made, when I add a producer, drop a carrier or get a new claims number? Theo: a sentence in chat, paid from the plan's monthly chat credits.

6. Does it link to my rater's quote page, my management system's client portal and each carrier's claims and billing pages? Theo: yes, in the first build.

7. Who owns the domain? Theo: you do, even for a domain bought inside Theo.

8. Is the search work included, or a separate monthly service? Theo: included on Starter and Pro, using no chat credits.

Pelloquin Insurance contact page, Call column, built by Theo: the phone number, weekday hours and a line saying the office line is forwarded to cell phones and answered 7:00am to 9:00pm when a hurricane warning is posted
Built by TheoPelloquin InsuranceThe hurricane line from the description, on the contact page right under the weekday hours.See the live site
16

What we typed to Theo for these sites

Each site began as a written description of an agency, then got four rounds of changes typed in the chat. The description gave its towns, its lines, its people, the phone number, the main button and what each page should say, and Theo built a starting draft from it. A few lines from those descriptions, word for word:

For Kettlehaus: 'Quote request form, with one sentence above it: "This form never asks for your driver's license number or your Social Security number."'

For Brunvald: 'Requests in by 2:00pm on a business day go out the same day, emailed to you and to the holder.'

For Pelloquin: 'When a hurricane warning is posted for the Coast, the office line is forwarded to our cell phones and answered 7:00am-9:00pm every day until our clients' claims are filed.'

For Solvanez: 'The site should make it easy to add a page for each new line later.'

For Hallendine, about the fall review letter: 'Most years the answer is stay, and that is worth knowing too.'

Not everything asked for got built. Kettlehaus asked for an upload for declarations pages and Brunvald for one for the contract's insurance page; Theo's forms take typed answers only, so the pages ask people to email the document or have it ready for the call.

The more your first description holds, such as claims lines, licenses and the response time you keep, the fewer changes come after.

Kettlehaus Insurance contact page on a phone, built by Theo: the number across the top, the Wausau office address, a tap-to-call number, the hours, and the start of the claims box
Built by TheoKettlehaus InsuranceOn a phone: the address, a number to tap, the hours with Thursday evenings and fall and winter Saturdays, then the claims box.See the live site
17

Check your agency's website in ten minutes

Open your site on your own phone and go down the list.

1. Does the first screen name the lines you write and the towns you write them in?

2. Are 'Get a quote' and a door for clients both on that screen, side by side?

3. Does the number dial with one tap, and does it say when someone answers?

4. Does the claims page list every current carrier's claims line, and nothing for a carrier you no longer write?

5. Is client service one tap from the header?

6. Does each line you write have its own page, and none for a line you cannot place?

7. Does the quote form ask four or five things, and never a license or Social Security number?

8. Do producers have real photos, the lines they handle and the states they are licensed in?

9. Are the licensed states, and the license number where your state wants it, in the footer as text?

10. Do carrier logos appear only where the carrier said yes?

11. Is the page free of pop-ups, chat bubbles over the call button, sliders and gift-card offers?

12. Do the address, hours and phone match your Google Business Profile, and if you sell Medicare, is the notice there with this year's counts?

The free audit covers what the phone test cannot, such as how many visitors the site gets from Google search, with no login.

Who this is for

Which agencies this fits

Theo fits the independent agency with an owner, a few producers and a CSR or two, where the owner is also the marketing department and the site has not changed since the last management system migration. It fits a solo producer who needs an insurance agent website before the first renewal cycle, a captive agent getting ready to go independent, a commercial office that lives on certificates, and an agency on an insurance website vendor's platform that wants pages written in its own words. Quoting, the client portal and premium payments stay in the rater, the management system and the carriers' portals, and the site links to each. Good insurance website design is mostly plain information in the order a client needs it, and that is the part Theo writes. An agent whose carrier supplies the agency site should read the agent agreement first.

Before you decide

What agency owners ask first

Four questions, in the words owners ask them, and the answers that settle the plan and the timing.

We have three producers and no marketing person. Who keeps the site current?

You do, or a producer or CSR you invite as a collaborator, by typing the change in chat: a new producer, a dropped carrier, holiday hours, a new claims number. On Starter and Pro, Theo drafts the weekly coverage, town and client-type pages and handles the fixes. On every plan, connecting Google also submits the agency's sitemap, so Google can find every new page. None of it uses chat credits, which pay for the changes you type. The office's recurring task is reviewing the new pages in the Growth tab and publishing the ones that read right, unless the office turns on auto-publish.

We are on an insurance website vendor's platform now. What moves and what stays?

Paste the current address, and Theo reads the site, matches the look and rebuilds the pages as a draft with the lines, carriers and towns filled in. The rater, the carrier portals and the management system stay where they are and the new site links to them. Once the owner signs in with Google, Theo sets up Search Console, Google's free dashboard for site owners, and submits the agency's sitemap through it on every plan, so Google finds every new page. On Starter and Pro, SEO repair points the agency's old addresses that still get search traffic at the matching new pages, and on Basic each redirect is a chat request. The old site stays live until the domain moves.

I am a new agent with no book yet. Do I need the search work from day one?

Not necessarily. Basic at $29.99 a month gives a new agent the site a referral checks: lines, licensed states, a bio, a quote path and the towns served. Starter, $69.99 a month and free for the first 30 days, is for the agent who wants calls from people searching for a line in those towns. The earlier the search work starts, the more pages exist when the book needs them. Build the site free first and decide after the preview.

I'm a captive agent about to go independent. When should the new site go up?

Build it before the move and publish it the day your new appointments start. Describe the agency to Theo rather than pasting the address of the page your current company supplies, and have ready the lines you will be able to place, the carriers you are appointed with and your new license details. Check what the old agreement says about contacting its clients before the site says anything to them. On day one, list the carriers by name as plain text until each one approves its logo, and add a short 'More on the way' note for lines still waiting on an appointment, the way Solvanez Insurance, the new agent's site above, does.

Included

What Theo handles

The build

Built from one conversation about the agency, the site has home, coverage-line, client-type, carriers, team, claims, service, reviews and contact pages, each carrying the quote button and the claims link. Theo's first preview is a starting draft, and the owner refines it in chat until the pages are right. An agency replacing an old site pastes its current address, and Theo reads that site and keeps the look clients know. Nothing is public until the owner publishes.

Hosting and security

Theo hosts the agency's site as static pages served over HTTPS, with no database to patch and no plugin to update. Policy documents are not stored on it either, because they stay in the management system and the carrier portals the site links to. Forms take typed answers only, with no file uploads, so declarations pages and policy documents never arrive through the website. Hosting is inside every plan, Basic included.

Changes in plain English

Type 'add a flood page under home', 'take that carrier off the carriers page and the claims list' or 'move commercial lines above personal lines' in the chat, and Theo makes the change. Drag a new producer's headshot in and it goes on the team page. Requests like these use chat credits, and each plan includes a monthly supply: 1,500 on Basic, 4,500 on Starter and 7,000 on Pro. A small edit such as a new headshot uses a little, a new coverage page more and a redesign the most. Top-up credits roll over and never expire.

Ongoing search work on Starter and Pro

Theo researches the coverage and town searches in the area you write in, drafts the pages and posts your site is missing and holds each one in the Growth tab until the owner publishes it, unless auto-publish is on. It also fixes technical issues, works on page speed and works toward citations in ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews. On every plan, connecting Google also submits the agency's sitemap. None of it draws chat credits, and it builds up over months. Which insurance searches are open to a local agency, and what that work did on an agency site Theo built, are on SEO for insurance agencies.

Google connections and listings

Once the domain is live, the owner signs in with Google once and Theo sets up Google Analytics and Search Console. On Starter and Pro, the Boost checklist then walks the owner through Google Business Profile, Apple Business Connect, Bing Places, Yelp and Facebook. With the checklist finished, the agency name, suite number, phone and hours match on every listing a shopper checks before calling.

Reports, conversion work and the pixel

On Starter and Pro, the Growth tab lists every page built and every fix made, and a weekly email counts the new pages, posts and updates. Over time the growth work also refines copy, calls to action, layout and page flow on pages such as the quote path and the client-type pages, aiming to turn more visits into requests. If the agency runs Meta or TikTok ads for a line, the pixel goes on the site.

Process

How it happens

1

Tell Theo about the agency

Insurance agency website development with Theo starts with a conversation, not a form to fill in. Start with the lines, carriers and producers, the states each producer is licensed in, the towns you write in, how a quote happens today and where a claim should be reported. Paste the rater's quote link and the carriers' claims and billing pages. If there is a current site, paste its address too and Theo keeps its look. The first build costs nothing and comes before any plan or trial.

2

Read the preview as a client would

The first preview is usually ready in minutes, with the main pages drafted and nothing public yet. As an insurance agency website builder, Theo hands you written pages to correct, not empty ones to fill. Read them on a phone the way a shopper would. Does the commercial auto page say what a quote needs? Is the claims page one tap away? Does the team page show the right licensed states? Drag in headshots, then ask for what is off: 'commercial lines first', 'the claims page in the menu', 'that carrier off'. Publish when it reads right.

3

Publish, then move the domain and connect Google

Theo walks the owner through pointing the agency's domain at the new site, both the root and www versions. The walkthrough also covers turning off forwarding or parking at the registrar and leaving the email records alone. An agency without a domain can buy one inside Theo. Until the new records take effect, usually within a few hours, the current site keeps serving clients, so the claims page is never out of reach. With the domain live, the owner signs in with Google once, Theo sets up Google Analytics and Search Console, and Starter and Pro owners work through the Boost checklist. Once Search Console is set up, SEO repair on Starter and Pro redirects any old address that still gets search traffic to the page that replaced it, and on any plan you can ask for a redirect in chat. A client's bookmarked claims page still lands where it should.

4

The search work starts

On Starter or Pro, the growth work switches on once the domain and both Google connections are in place. From then on, each week brings new coverage, town and client-type pages and posts, along with technical fixes and page speed work. New pages wait in the Growth tab until the owner publishes them, or go live as they are written once auto-publish is on. A weekly email counts what was added. None of it uses chat credits. On Basic the site changes only when the owner asks in chat.

Pricing

What it costs, in full

The site, hosting and chat editing start on Basic. Starter adds the ongoing search work and is free for the first 30 days.

PlanPer monthOngoing search workChat creditsBest for
Basic$29.99Not included1,500 a monthOwners who just want their site live and easy to update.
Pro$129.99Included, uses no credits7,000 a monthOwners who want more capacity, more publishing, and more room to experiment.

No contract, cancel anytime, and you own the site and its content. The pricing page lists what each plan includes and how chat credits work.

Reviews

What customers say

Rated 4.8 out of 5 on Trustpilot from 42 reviews.

Theo is the best in the game. I was originally forking over hundreds of dollars for a website hosting service only to be on the third page of Google search, but with Theo, I have a gorgeous site constantly optimizing SEO and actually getting me conversions. Truly life changing stuff, couldn’t be more grateful

Greg on Trustpilot

Theo is a fantastic platform, not only from a build and usability standpoint, but in terms of real, measurable performance. The platform is intuitive, well thought out, and easy to work with. More importantly, we saw significant lifts in a remarkably short period of time, and the analytics gave us a clear view into what was driving it. It has been genuinely impressive to see how quickly Theo makes an impact.

Tom Drymalski on Trustpilot

This tool is amazing! Truly the best bespoke AI tool that I've come across in the past year. The website design capabilities are tremendous, and even though I've only experienced 2 months of how Theo can support with SEO, the increases in traction we saw were significant. I've been telling everyone I know who could benefit from Theo to start using it today.

Josh Buoy on Trustpilot

Compare

Theo against the alternatives

TheoInsurance website vendorDIY builder, web guy or your nephew
Monthly cost$29.99 Basic for the site and hosting; $69.99 Starter with the search work, free for 30 days; $129.99 ProAs of October 2026, three platforms post $89, $97 and $170 a month, and a fourth posts four plans from $49 to $199 a month. Some charge extra for design or sell a one-time buildA subscription, his fee, or a free look at his auto policy
Published priceYes, on the pricing page and on this oneNot at the two largest platforms we read, which ask for a sales demo first (October 2026)The builder's is posted; his is usually a quote or a favor
Time to launchThe first preview usually in minutes; you publish when it reads rightThree days at one platform, two weeks or less at another and three weeks or less at a third, as each stated in October 2026Whenever the last page gets written, renewal season permitting
The owner's timeOne conversation, then reading the preview and typing changes in chatAbout two hours at one platform: two 30-minute calls and an hour of review (October 2026)Evenings writing the pages, or explaining umbrella coverage to him
Who writes the coverage-line and client-type pagesTheo, from one conversation about your lines, written for your agencyPre-written pages that other agencies' sites carry too: 80+ policy types at one platform, 70+ pages at another (October 2026)You, between renewals; he can build the page, but the words come from you
A new producer or a dropped carrierOne line in chatThe vendor's editor or a change request; one platform includes a set number of developer changes each quarterYou in the editor, or a text to him with the new name
New pages and posts after launchDrafted weekly on Starter and Pro for your review, using no chat creditsBlog posts from a shared library at some platforms; search work is often a separate serviceOnly the ones you write, or ask him for
Quote, claims and service linksIn the first build, to the tools the agency already runsQuote forms, plus webchat, texting or rater links at some platformsAdded by hand, one carrier link at a time
Ownership and leavingYours: pages, words and photos. Cancel any month and save your text and images first; Pro adds read-only code accessRead the contract: at one large platform the site is shut down when you cancel, and you rebuild elsewhere with a new design (October 2026)Your words go with you; ask now whose login the site is under

FAQ

Questions buyers ask

How much does an insurance agency website cost?

With Theo, the site and hosting are $29.99 a month on Basic, and the first build is free before any plan. Starter is $69.99 a month, free for the first 30 days, and adds the weekly search work. Pro is $129.99 a month, with more weekly pages and read-only access to the site code. Beyond the plan price, the paid extras are top-up credits, a domain bought through Theo and the optional paid directory submission packages that Starter and Pro offer in the Boost checklist. Insurance website platforms price it their own ways: as of October 2026, a few post monthly prices, the two largest quote after a sales demo, and some add setup fees or a one-time build. The comparison table above lines them up. The website cost guide covers what design shops charge, and pricing explains what a chat credit is.

How long until the site is live?

The first preview is usually ready in minutes. After that, the agency sets the pace: read the pages as a client would, send changes in chat, collect headshots and publish when the site reads right. The domain moves when you say so. The switch usually lands within a few hours, and the old site keeps answering clients until it does.

Do I own the website, and are the words mine?

Yes. The coverage pages, bios and office photos are yours, and Theo writes them for your agency instead of lending you pages from a shared library that leave when you do. Theo hosts the site for you. The domain stays yours as well, and one bought inside Theo is registered in your name, not Theo's. If you sell the book, you can save the text and images for the buyer's new site. On Pro, the code is also readable through read-only GitHub access, and you can copy it.

Can I cancel?

Yes, any month, with no term contract. Say you sign up before the January renewals and decide in April that referrals are enough. You cancel from the account, and the confirmation shows the date the subscription ends. The site stays live until the end of the paid period, so you can save the text and images you want before then.

Is Theo an insurance agency website builder?

Yes, of a different kind. There is no editor to learn and no design to pick from a gallery: you describe the agency, and Theo writes and lays out the pages, from the coverage lines to the claims page. Changes happen by typing them, such as 'add a flood page under home' or 'put the claims number in the header'. Most builders hand you the tools and leave the work to you. Theo builds the site itself and, on Starter and Pro, does the weekly work of getting the agency found.

Can I see insurance agency websites Theo has built?

Yes. The six sites near the top of this page were built by Theo: a family home and auto office, a contractors-only commercial agency, a Gulf Coast flood agency, a life and benefits practice, a new agent working from referrals and a Medicare agency for people turning 65. Every card has the home page on a computer and a phone, three inner pages, and a link to the live site, where you can try the quote form and the menus yourself. Sites for other kinds of business are on the examples page. Live customer sites in insurance are shared on request, where their owners have agreed to it; ask on the contact page.

Is this an insurance agency website template?

No. Theo does not sell templates, and there is none to pick. It writes each agency's site from what the owner tells it, which is why the contractor agency above has a certificate page and a page per trade, while the flood agency has a storm checklist and a page on named-storm timing: those are what their clients ask about. Two agencies that describe themselves differently get different pages, words and layouts. If clients already know your current site's look, Theo can keep it, working from the site's address.

Will the site bring in quote requests?

Google decides rankings, and Theo does not promise any. What Theo does on Starter and Pro is the work behind quote requests, built up over months. Each line and each town gets a page, so the agency can show for 'commercial auto insurance' in its county and not only for its own name. Technical fixes then help Google find and read those pages. If the agency has a site today, the free audit shows what it gets from Google search now, with no login. The guide to getting on Google explains each step.

Can the site quote, bind or take premium payments?

No. Quoting and binding stay in the rater and the carrier portals, premium payments go to each carrier's billing page, and the site links to all of them. The 'Get a quote' button opens the rater's quote page, and the service page links to the management system's client portal. Each tool keeps its own logins, data and payments.

Your industry

Questions specific to what you do

How do I build an insurance agency website?

In four steps. First, gather what the site will say: the lines you write and the ones you cannot place yet, the towns, the carriers, each producer's lines and licensed states, your rater's quote link if you have one, each carrier's claims line and billing page, and the response time your office keeps. Second, describe the agency to Theo, or paste your current site's address, and read the first preview on your phone as a client would. Third, ask in chat for what is off and publish when it reads right. Fourth, point your domain at the new site and connect Google, which is when the search work starts on Starter and Pro. The first preview is usually ready in minutes; the review takes as long as you want it to.

What should an insurance agency website include, and how many pages?

On the first screen: the lines and towns in one sentence, a quote button, a separate door for clients, a phone number that dials, and the licensed states. Behind it: a page per line you write and per kind of client you want more of, plus quote, claims, client service, carriers, team, towns and contact pages, and certificates if you write commercial. A one-office personal lines agency usually starts with 15 to 20 pages and adds town pages as it grows. The pages point above lists each one and what goes on it.

Do insurance agents need a website?

Yes, even an agent who lives on referrals. A referred client looks the agent up before calling, to check that the name, the license and the lines match what the friend said, and an agent with no site, or one that has not changed in years, quietly loses some of those calls. Shoppers without a referral search a line and a town, such as 'landlord insurance Evans GA', and only an agency with a page for that line can show up. A Google Business Profile helps, but it has no room for coverage pages, a claims list or producer bios.

Can a captive agent have their own website?

It depends on the agent agreement, not on the website. Agents who sell for a single company often work under a contract that sets what they may publish, and many of those companies supply the agent's page and its rules. Read the agreement, or ask your field office, before building a separate site, and ask whether the company must approve it. If it is allowed, keep the site to what the agreement permits and name the company only the way it says. An agent going independent can build the site before the move and publish the day the new appointments start.

Do insurance agency websites have compliance requirements?

Yes, from three directions. Your state sets the license rules, such as the name you advertise under and, in some states, the license number on advertising. Your carriers set brand rules for their names and logos and often approve ads for a named product. Federal rules bar fake or bought reviews and, for agents who sell Medicare plans for more than one plan company, require a standard notice on the website. The rules points above explain each. Nothing is public until you publish, and growth pages wait for your review unless you turn on auto-publish, so the agency decides what goes out.

Can the site work for a Medicare agent?

Yes, with three things in place. The notice the rules require of agents who sell for more than one Medicare Advantage plan company, with this year's counts, on the home page and in the footer. A page for the Annual Enrollment Period, October 15 to December 7, that says what to bring. And a booking link that starts with the Scope of Appointment form your agency uses. Theo builds the pages and places the notice; the counts and any carrier approvals come from you. Hallendine Medicare Advisors, the sixth site above, has a notice in every footer, a Fall Review page for the enrollment period and a booking page that explains the Scope of Appointment form; take the notice's exact words from the rule, as the Medicare point above explains.

Is structured data important for an insurance agency website?

It helps. Structured data is a few lines of code that tell search engines and AI assistants the agency's name, address, phone and the towns it serves, in a form they read without guessing. It does not replace pages, but it removes doubt about who and where you are. Each of the six sites above carries InsuranceAgency structured data with its name, address and phone, added by Theo during the build. Theo adds it only where it matches what the page shows, and never adds ratings or reviews that do not exist.

Which insurance tools does the site work with?

The site links to whatever the office already runs, starting with the comparative rater's or a carrier's online quote page. Each carrier's claims and billing portals get a link, and so does the management system's client portal if the office has one. Coverage reviews can be booked on the site itself or through Calendly, Acuity or Square Appointments. Theo runs none of those tools. When the agency changes raters or management systems, a short message in chat updates the links.

Can carrier logos go on the site?

Only with the carrier's permission, and only for current appointments. Until the carriers have been asked, a carriers page can list names alone. When an appointment ends, a single request in chat removes the logo, the carrier's name from the coverage pages and its claims line from the claims page. A client is then never sent to a carrier the agency no longer represents.

Where do licensing and service area go?

The licensed states go in the footer beside the office address and on each producer's bio, with the license number wherever your state requires it on advertising. The towns and counties the agency writes in get a line on the home page. On Starter and Pro, each one can also get its own page over time, drafted for your review, so someone searching for a line plus a town can find a page about that town. The page on local business web design explains how town pages and the listings work together.

What should the site say to existing clients about policy changes and certificates of insurance?

Give them a service page of their own, reachable from the header, so they never land in the quote path. That page says how to request a policy change, an ID card or a certificate of insurance by phone, email or the management system's client portal. It also lists what the office needs for each request and links each carrier's billing page for payments. A contractor who needs a certificate before tomorrow's job finds the path in one tap.

Does the site help with Google reviews and the Google Business Profile listing?

Yes, in two ways. First, the site links to the agency's Google reviews next to the quote button. Second, it carries the same name, address, phone and hours as the Google Business Profile listing. The Boost checklist on Starter and Pro walks you through setting that listing up. Review requests come from the producer after a policy is bound.